From the frying pan to the fire

15 December, 2007 (19:26) | Journal | By: Colin McGinley

This time last week I had a plan in place in the run up to the Fed interest rate announcement taking place on Tuesday. I was holding my positions in EUR-USD and AUD-USD looking for the US dollar to weaken slightly on Monday and Tuesday morning.

At the back of my mind I was contemplating just going all square on my trades if price was in positive territory (i.e. above my average entry point for the multiple trades I was holding) just ahead of the Fed rate announcement.

By noon on Tuesday price was indeed in positive territory, by about 50 pips in either pair. It was decision time. Should I just square everything and walk away, not even caring what the Fed decision turned out to be? This action would allow me to close out my trades for a slight profit and be able to take the rest of the month off, something I have been meaning to do, especially considering my lamentations on needing a break for a few weeks.

Maybe I could close out all my positions and just re-enter a small trade on EUR-USD to catch any further dollar weakness that might result?

The final option was to do nothing. The rationale for this non-action was to be able to profit handsomely from a surprise 50 basis point cut from the Fed which would send the dollar tumbling. Since I had such large positions on already this could mean a huge windfall.

The decision I went with was the last option, of doing nothing. Of going for the possibility of a 50bps cut. Of trying to make back up the losses that I had suffered in November in one fell swoop. Of being too greedy.

In retrospect, especially after the huge surge of the US dollar yesterday, the correct course of action would have been to go with my gut and close everything out and walk away for the rest of the year.

I made a Mistake. With a capital M. This mistake is most likely going to cost me a large chunk of my profits from the last three months.

Friday’s 300+ pip surge by the dollar on EUR-USD shows that there is definitely life left in the old dog yet. Price ended the week just above 1.44, more than 550 pips from the high in mid-November. I think we’re on a knife end here and the upcoming holidays are going to mean that the volatility and large moves are not done yet.

From here price could easily tumble down to 1.40 or climb back to 1.48.

The fundamentals point to the dollar weakness being still very much in play. The US PPI and CPI inflation data that fuelled the dollar move on Friday points to less likelihood of another Fed cut at the end of January. At the same time new Euro zone inflation figures point to inflation at over 3% which can only strengthen the case for a possible ECB rate hike, or at the very least, continued hawkish commentary from Trichet.

While the fundamentals point to further long-term dollar weakness (over the next couple of years) the technicals and my gut point to continued dollar strength for the medium term. I’m thinking the next three or four months here. The upward trendline on the euro surge ending in November has been broken to the downside. There is no chatter from the financial talking heads of the euro going to 1.55 or 1.60 any time soon. In fact, they are mainly talking about the euro declining slightly (the 1.4 handle is often mentioned as a 2008 year end price).

Price action on Monday and potential Tuesday this coming week is crucial to me ending out this year with anything worthwhile to show for it.

If price continues to drop then I’m pretty much screwed. I have two euro trades of far too high leverage 300 pips in the red right now. Similarly, on AUD-USD I also have two trades far too far underwater, one 300 pips the other 400. If this scenario unfolds then I’m going to have to realise those losses and just deal with a significant portion of trading capital being wiped out.

While a continued drop is a definite possibility I think it is slightly more likely that there will be a retrace of Friday’s move. The amount of retrace, if it does occur, will be key. If we retrace all the way back up to where price was on Thursday (at least above 1.46) then I think things will return to a slightly bullish if not rangebound nature. If this price action unfolds then I’ll probably hold on in to see if 1.47 is at least on the cards and I’ll hopefully be able to close at sometime close to breakeven. Such a steep move down followed by an equally abrupt move back up reminds me of the ‘railroad’ price pattern I came across in DiNapoli’s book. It’s often seen as a pretty bullish signal.

If price moves to above 1.45 but doesn’t break 1.46 then I think the downward price action is still very much in play. In this situation I’ll look to get out of my higher up entries. I’ll have to take on board the losses but at least they’ll be of a much more manageable size.

The last scenario is that price just meanders in the 1.44 handle all day. If that happens I’ll be in a sort of twilight zone waiting for one of the other above scenarios to unfold. My view is that the longer price stays down close to 1.44 the greater the chance of continued weakness. I won’t want to give it too much time to figure out where to go next. I’ll have to just cut my losses if no clear direction has emerged by Tuesday.

Of course I don’t have to close out all my underwater positions at once. This allows me some degree of flexibility to close out one or two trades at the first sign of continued trouble and then look to close the other trades at more favourable levels.

My options for entering new longs at these low levels are limited, especially given the thin margin of downside I have remaining with my currently open positions. I really need to see a solid base form here with pressure materialising to the upside before I can enter any substantial new longs. If I do get the chance to do that I can obviously bring down my average open position and extradite myself from this situation all the quicker.

I find myself back in damage control mode after having found myself a path out of my initial troubles from mid-November. I just didn’t follow through with my original plan and have found myself straight back in hot water.

I’ve definitely learnt about what works and what doesn’t work for me during this tumultuous period. Now all I have to do is survive this drawdown and make sure to follow through with my original intentions on how to go about that.

Related Posts:

Comments

Comment from caprica
Time 16 December, 2007 at 5:36 am

Did you have a disaster stop just below the bottom of your grid or are you still holding open positions and a big drawdown?

btw. I agree with you on the long term fundamental direction of the USD, but I had taken most of my positions out of the market at the end of november feeling that the low liquidity in december could create a wild ride. I am still sitting and waiting for the resumption of the trend before my toes goes back in the water, perhaps in the new year.

Comment from Igor Podolsky
Time 16 December, 2007 at 8:43 am

Hello, Colin.
You say you see 3-4 months of short term dollar strenght. You trade in the direction of the long term trend – to the dollar weakness. Does it mean that you’ll sit sideways all these 4 months waiting for the long term trend assure itself or you’ll try to play short trend, thus violating your strategy?

Comment from Colin McGinley
Time 16 December, 2007 at 11:06 pm

@caprica:
I did not have a disaster stop in place; I rarely ever do, instead relying on mental stops which I can obviously only put into practice whenever I’m actively monitoring the market.

As I mention in my latest post, even when I see the correction coming a mile off I still don’t seem to get out of the way. My post about The Economist front page is a prime example. The dollar bulls were sure to come out and play. Yet even when I had my chance to go all square and sit back and wait I didn’t take it.

@Igor:
Even though I see the dollar trend in the very long term still being bearish, I don’t think I’ll be sitting it out until the dollar starts to get thumped again.

If you look at the dollar bull move in EUR-USD during 2005, any dollar strengthening move can go on for quite a while. We might be looking at a similar sort of scenario unfolding here, even in the face of future Fed cuts and high eurozone inflation.

Long-term means different time frames for different people.

For me and my trading plan it generally equates to the next six or so months. Therefore if I think the dollar is going to strengthen during that period that becomes my one direction and I’ll go with it.

I think it’s going to be very hard to get any true picture of the trend for next year from what happens in the rest of December. There is too little volume and too much volatility around this time to base any real decisions on.

Write a comment

You need to login to post comments!