March 2008 Review
There is one word that sums up my final two weeks of trading in March: whipsaw. I was shaken out of just about every position I entered during that time period.
My trading head just wasn’t screwed on right during this time. Trading was well down on my list of priorities. Top of the list was a crazy crunch period at work to meet a milestone deadline. If you’ve ever worked in the video games industry you’ll be intimately aware of the joy that is crunch mode. Next on the priority list was a ton of legwork related to house hunting, as well as a lot of work to declutter, fix up and prepare our current residence for sale.
Needless to say after all that there wasn’t much time left to properly dedicate myself to trading. It’s not just the time element in and of itself that was the issue. I generally don’t need all that much time to actively keep up to date and manage my trades. It was more that my energy level was severely depleted by the time I was able to focus on making trading decisions.
I think my trading results are a pretty good mirror of my trading ability since my last post.
While my equity was up around 8% by the middle of the month, I ended March down 17.68%.
With 58 trades closed out during the month, I think it is pretty clear that I overtraded as this number of positions is significantly higher than my usual amount.
The worst of my sins was being overleveraged on some whipsaw moves.
The first of these were entered on the Sunday evening after the Bear Stearns news had broken. USD-CHF had just surged past parity all the way down to 0.9650, while USD-JPY had broken through 100, falling to just under 96. I entered both short after a bounce back looking for a test of the new lows before the Fed meeting on the upcoming Tuesday.
I had been looking for some US dollar strength to materialise around that time. When it didn’t come from the ECB rate meeting the previous week, I was looking to see if the Fed meeting might be a catalyst. For this reason I wasn’t looking to go long EUR-USD on the Bears news. I felt Yen and Swissy would be better plays and would continue or at least hold their runs in the face of any dollar strength.
I was wrong. When the Fed ‘only’ cut by 75bps, both JPY and CHF got hit hard, with yen seeing its weakest day in many years against the dollar.
I switched to a dollar long viewpoint, and was rather stupidly geared 6:1 short on EUR-USD at the start of last week when the Euro made a strong comeback. The worst decision I made was probably on Monday evening, when there was a strong euro surge during the Asian session. Instead of closing out and reversing my positions, just like I had done earlier in the month, I pushed back my stops to give my trades more room to breath. Which obviously just ended up costing me more money when the stop loss positions were eventually hit.
I feel despondent that I let myself make such bad trading decisions. I am my own worst enemy far too often it seems.
I’ve even had some whimsical thoughts that I should maybe just chuck the whole trading thing in. I don’t even think that thought ever really crossed my mind in a serious way last December, when I had a much worse month.
It’s probably born from frustration. For every two steps forward I take I’m staggering back two steps at the moment. While the markets have been clearly all over the place, with no clearly defined trends evident during the month, my trading decisions were equally haphazard.
I think a key element is recognising when not to trade. When I’m tired or too busy with other things I shouldn’t be trading. The majority of times I can actually recognise these signs. The problem is that I never act on it. I’m probably in the middle of managing some open trades, or trying to jump back in the market to chase back a loss that has just been incurred. Bad, bad, bad. I always put it off until tomorrow, or the day after, or next week.
The result is that my trading decisions suffer and I end up losing money. There’s a lesson to be learnt here once again. Will I learn it this time?
Last week I had entered using the Anti-Hedge method to get back into my JPY and CHF trades that got closed out the after the Fed meeting. While both meandered in and out of profitability over the few days, neither currency made a sustained move towards the previous lows and after seeing this morning’s US dollar strength I closed out both before they hit their stop losses. Throw in another EUR-USD 1:1 long entered at 1.5772 that I closed out in the red this morning, and my month is already off to a not so terrific drop of 13% (those initial CHF and JPY were rather too highly leveraged, and thus so were the resulting AH entries).
There is a small ray of light in a short GBP-USD position I have open which should recoup part of those losses, but after that I think I’ll be taking a trading break for a week or so.
I have to fly over to Ireland to attend my sister’s wedding this weekend, which means I won’t be able to follow the markets on Thursday or Friday. Seems like a no brainer that I should step back and get refreshed and recharged. If I don’t I have the funny feeling that every new trade I place is an attempt to recover as quickly as possible the losses I’ve just taken. Instead of being able to look at each trade in isolation I find myself comparing what profit target needs to be hit to make up for my last loss.
I need to break the cycle. Eliminate the temptation. Rest.

3 Comments so far ...
Don’f feel like you are alone. A few professional traders of stocks on the NYSE floor have thought about throwing in the towel recently also. They have not seen volatility like this in their 30 years of trading. You sound like you are on overload. The human brain can only take so much drawdown and confusion before the natural chemicals produced within the brain cause the thinking process to go awry.
I used to trade stocks and options from 1999 thru 2004. I had 4 brokers. Two at Morgan Stanley (Chuck and Dick) and two down in Atlanta Georgia (Jim and Andy). I used Jim and Andy the for real creative option and index trading and Chuck and Dick for long or short stock and straight option tactics. In March of 2003 during horrendous drawdowns of his clients accounts in a bear of a bear market Dick unfortunately had had enough. He went home on a Friday and Saturday morning took his life with a shotgun in his bedroom. He left behind a wife and a one year old daughter. Just two weeks later the market turned up and started on the run to 15,000. I am not implying at all that you had any thoughts of that. I wanted only to illustrate how far it can go at times.
What I am getting at is back off, regroup, watch a very few chosen or maybe one currency pair and get the mind set back to proper operating condition. There is a reason why people have jumped out of windows during bad markets. No person is supposed to be in race to see who can do the most. Us guys are single task oriented,the women love to hear us admit this! That is how we are wired in the brain. As a matter of fact my brother just went into pullback mode from the stock market. Too much volatilty and bad judgement on his part. I told him to walk away for a while but keep in tune with only watching the market untill he gets it together again.
Hey, put the fun back into this. If it is no fun anymore then it is time to fold. I think you still want to have fun doing this. Maybe keep trading tactics simple. I plan on that, takes alot of stress away. We all know what stress does to use. It takes the smile and turns it into a frown. Now go and have some fun….I am….
Talk later,
Comment on April 2, 2008 08:00 pmRandy
Randy, great comment. I definitely don’t want my trading to drag me down. It is important that it stays vibrant, interesting, and challenging. It needs to remain a positive force in my life and so I need to really know when I’m in the right frame of mind and when I need to back off and take a break. This is obviously one trading skill I need to work on at the moment.
Comment on April 2, 2008 09:44 pmHi Colin,
Though I have not done this for long, I must say, I am learning some of these lessons quite quickly thanks in part to your website and other teachers out there like Gross, Du Toit et. al. I would like to say, that sometimes it is better not to be fully invested. In other words, don’t take a position just because you need to make creative use of your trading account to further your profits.
The current market has high levels of schizophrenic behaviour due to policy makers giving us contradictory information and corporate CEOs covering their abysmal earnings. One day, Big B says things are OK, dollar is rallying like mad, and the next day, things are all over the place because Nikkei has gone down the toilet by 500 points because Japanese officials are not enthusiastic about the dismal future ahead, and yet another day, some idiot Analyst comes on a TV show (hint hint) and says that “US Banking is in a generally strong position.” - you see the picture I am trying to paint here?
I have gone from a point of targetting a set amount of pips to “take whatever I get reasonably” mode. For example, just two days ago I had an opportunity to place a very nice trade at (almost) bottom of the median grid for AUD/USD around 0.9090. Instead of pulling the usual leverage of ~5:1, I kept it at a measly 2:1. On Friday during the Asian session, the position was up by 84 pips and I just pulled the trigger button to close all the lots. During the European and US session crossover, the Aud/Usd went even higher to 0.92 levels but I didn’t bother entering the market again, because (a) Fridays are just bad days for entering trades so far from my experience (b) I am in “once bitten twice shy mode” and (c) market sentiment seems to gyrate very quickly to the downside on even a slither of bad news.
I am sure some of these are just beginner problems but as I said, one key lesson I’ve learnt is that I would rather spend the weekend or a week knowing my account is safe and I can just relax. I would like to call them trading holidays and when I get even more serious with my account I intend to take them. One should just hold back their account if they think market conditions are looking VERY choppy and/or if they are mentally drained. Seems like obvious ramble, but it’s funny how many times it can be ignored if not taken seriously.
Wish you good luck for next month and trip to Ireland. If you plan to come to UK give me a shout, will take you for some pints.
Snake (you-know-who).
Comment on April 4, 2008 11:21 pmYou must be logged in to post a comment.