Category Archives: Money Management

Fact checking

Over the weekend I decided it was time I got back to catching up the small stack of trading books I have sitting on the shelf. Unsure as to which one to read first I picked out two and read the first 30 pages of each to see which piqued my interest more.

The two books battling it out were Day Trading the Currency Markets by Kathy Lien and Mastering the Trade by John Carter.

Kathy Lien’s book did not get off to the most promising start. In the first chapter, the forex market is explained and then compared to equities and futures. Somehow the forex market is better in every way; those pesky equity and futures markets are only open for a few hours a day. Examples are given of how expensive the spread and commission can be in a potential stock or future trade while nothing is mentioned about the large variety of spreads that exist on different currency pairs.

To my tough and cynical eyes the unbalanced comparison of forex to other tradable markets was nothing more than thinly veiled hype. What makes the cynicism all too easy to believe in is that Kathy Lien works for FXCM, one of the largest retail forex brokers around.

Statements of supposed fact are also uttered that had me raising my eyebrows in slight disbelief. For example:

“Most futures traders are technical traders, and as mentioned in the equities section, the FX market is perfect for technical analysis. In fact, it is the most commonly used analysis tool by professional traders.” (p. 12)

How exactly was that fact arrived at? Where’s the evidence? To me it just seemed to be a set-up: let the reader know that most of the pros make their money using technical analysis techniques, and then later in the book I’m sure there’s plenty of technical systems for them to try out.

The subtlety and sneakiness of this leapt out at me when I switched over and started to read John Carter’s Mastering the Trade.

John Carter kicks off Chapter 2 on Psychology 101 (always a good sign when trading psychology is placed way before any mention of markets or systems), with a section titled: Show me a guy with a system, and I’ll show you a guy who is welcome in my casino.

Any trader who is not 100% confident in their trading system ends up tweaking and modifying it when they experience a run of bad trades. The market has changed so I’d better re-jig my system parameters. This introduces the risk of making a mistake, such as by over-optimizing the system or getting flustered and over-riding your system’s signals.

“In the casinos, as in trading, it only takes one stupid bet to blow the whole wad. Casino owners know this, and this is why they sell the strategy books right there on the property, prominently displayed in their own gift shops. This elevates the concept of the fox guarding the hen house to a whole new level.” (p. 19)

While I’m sure Kathy Lien is a lovely lady, I think I’m going to stay clear of the foxes for now.

Aftermath

It’s been two days since the fateful day when I blew up my account.

I’ve spent that time trying to ween myself off the markets. I don’t have charts up permanently and I don’t have to keep monitoring Bloomberg constantly. I still pop up the charts occasionally, out of morbid curiosity more than anything else, to see if the markets kept going against me or if they finally turned around. AUD-USD seems to have made a stab moving back up, most likely linked to the slight rise in gold, while the euro is still languishing away.

It’s amazing how powerful the urge to just get back in there and try to fix things is. I know that doing any such thing would be absolutely wrong, but it doesn’t prevent my mind trying to fix whatever is broken in my trading methodology as quickly as possible.

It was especially curious on Wednesday and Thursday when I found myself mentally reviewing technical indicators that I have favourable tendencies towards (i.e. ones that I consider to have at least some worth). The technical indicators in question generally come from work done by Joe DiNapoli or Joe Ross.

I would throw up a 3×3 Displaced Moving Average on the chart or try to visualise how well a Ross Hook would have worked. I’d be looking at the charts from the past two months trying to see whether these indicators would have been any help in averting where I have ended up.

I don’t think there’s anything wrong or bad in doing this.

What does strike me is that in doing this I am probably looking for certainty. I’m feeling lost at sea Every part of my trading methodology is now in question and will have to be closely examined to determine if it is still fit to stick around.

Technical indicators are visual and ever present right there on the chart. You can build hard and fast rules up around them.

Except that deep down I really do know that the certainty that they supposedly represent is just an illusion. I’ve gone through this flailing around and fight with uncertainty before. I’m sure I’ll have further relapses in the future. For now I just have to let them wash over me until their eerie, seductive pull abates.

Trading is uncertainty. It is risk and randomness and chaos.

What can be tamed and controlled is me. I am the key to unlocking consistent money from the markets.

I am the one who is responsible for blowing up my account. The market didn’t take my money. My broker didn’t cheat me out of it. I’m the one who pulled the trigger on the trades. I’m the one who decided what and when to buy. I’m the one who didn’t have a disaster money management plan in place. I’m the one who ended up trading over leveraged positions. I’m the one who let things build up to breaking point. I’m the one who didn’t step back and take a break when I started to make poor trading decisions. I’m the one who didn’t want to cut his losses in the face of a correction that I knew was coming. The responsibility lies solely with me.

The power to fix things and turn them around also lies with me.

Going forward I need to be critical of my current trading plan but I don’t want to throw out the baby with the bath water.

There are many strengths to my current trading plan, aspects of viewing the markets and trading them that suit me well.

There are also now obvious weaknesses that I must remedy to eliminate or mitigate against. These mainly lie in the money management and psychological aspects of my trading. My thoughts on implementing a fixed 100 pip stop loss on every trade is obviously one of the main cures I’m looking at for my money management woes.

On the psychological side of things I’m thinking that I really need to enact a positive feedback cycle. When I do well in a given month I need to have more than just the satisfaction of my trading account being up going into the next month.

A potential course of action that I am seriously considering taking is to withdrawal somewhere around 25% of the profits during a month. When that 25% of profits comes out I’ll have to put aside the tax due on that amount, but I’ll also be able to do something with money that I’ve actually made trading. I’ll be able to take my wife out for dinner, or buy a video game. By turning my successful trading activities into something tangible and real I’ll be able to reinforce the positive aspects of what I’m doing. I’m hoping that it will help to keep me energised and positive going forward.

The only downside is that these monthly withdrawals will diminish the compounding growth of my trading account. Of course if it prevents the possibility of another blow up from ever occurring again then it will have been well worth it.

Looking to take monthly withdrawals from profits made also presents a major shift in my long-term trading objectives.

I am sure that I’m not the only aspiring trader who has the goal of becoming a full-time forex trader. Earlier this month I would have said that if I was able to keep to my consistent returns of the past year I might be able to reach that goal in two, maybe three years.

Funny how things can change so dramatically.

After what happened on Wednesday I now have to face the stark reality that while my goal is still achievable, it is rather further off then I had previously thought.

I need to have a change in perception. Instead of my trading activities being solely dedicated to reaching the goal of being a full-time trader I want to switch and view trading as an active part of my life right now. Shooting for only the full-time trading goal is an all or nothing prospect. I either am or am not a full-time trader. The longer I solely focus on just that the longer the negativity of what I am not weighs on me.

A change in perspective is sorely needed. If I can withdraw profits every month consistently then I become a consistent, profitable trader now. I will get to benefit from any success I have now. The long-term goal of becoming a full-time trader can remain in place but I able to enjoy the fruits of my labours along the way.

I think this change is going to be a crucial underpinning of my trading going forward.

I certainly don’t hate my current full-time job. It has its highs and lows just like most jobs I guess. It even has its fun and sense of accomplishment when something turns out well. By only focusing on the trading as a full-time gig as-soon-as-possible scenario I have not paid as much attention to what my goals were with the regular job. If I was going to be doing nothing but trading soon then there wasn’t much need, or so I thought.

Now I see that there is a need to keep things in balance. It is foolhardy to ignore trying to advance my non-trading career.

I am also going to get back to some other hobbies that I used to love. I often spend so much time trading that I neglect other activities that I really enjoy doing.

I need to focus more on living and enjoying the here and now. If I can purge the weaknesses from my trading plan and play to my strengths then my goals will become reality in time.

I need to enjoy the journey and not focus so much on the destination.

Happy holidays. I hope everyone is able to have a joyous time with family and friends as we count down to the end of 2007.

Money Management Flux

One of the recent changes to my trading plan was an update to my position sizing. In effect I doubled my gearing as compared to what I had been using. I use a different gearing size dependent on what quadrant of my trading grid price is currently in when the trade is opened. Doubling my gearing had the following impact:

  • Q4: 1:1 -> 2:1
  • Q3: 2:1 -> 4:1
  • Q2: 3:1 -> 6:1
  • Q1 4:1 -> 8:1

Another recent change to my trading plan has been the introduction of USD-JPY to my trading roster. It is currently unclear whether the carry trade is really dead and buried; it seems to be on life support at the moment, with a tug of war going on with carry trade believers testing the waters against those who think the carry trade is finished.

If I wait till this struggle is over I’ll potentially miss out on some significant strengthening of the Japanese Yen. My opinion is that the yen has enough legs to appreciate considerably over the next six to twelve months, even taking into account the indecisive Japanese economic data.

Doubling the number of currency pairs being traded while also doubling my gearing has been nagging at me lately; it seems to be taking on too much risk too quickly.

To that end I am going to be scaling back my gearing. I’m going to split the difference and set my gearing levels to:

  • Q4: 1.5:1
  • Q3: 3:1
  • Q2: 4.5:1
  • Q1: 6:1

Another recent addition to my trading strategy has been the introduction and usage of the Anti-Hedge trade (as termed by Jacko on Forex Factory). This tactic is nothing more than re-entering a trade at the point at which it had been stopped out. You cut your loss early but are unafraid to put that trade back on once price is moving back in the direction of the main trend.

I have thinking if it would be possible to make greater use of this approach. One of the main reasons for using low geared trades in the upper quadrants of my grid is to be able to hold those trades open if price goes against me. I have generally held those upper quadrant trades open up to 200 pips against me; trying to give them breathing room before taking my loss when price is far below the price I had originally entered at. What I need to do is to check my trade history and try to determine if holding those trades open for an extended period of time has been worth it. My gut feeling is that if price has generally gone more than 100 pips against me in the past then, in the majority of cases, I have had to close out those trades at the 200 pip marker.

Would I be better off just cutting those trades short earlier on? Employing the Anti-Hedge entry technique I will now always re-enter those trades once price comes back to the stop-loss price.

Using the Anti-Hedge method there will of course be times when my stop loss is hit and price then immediately surges back in the main trend direction. I will therefore have taken a loss without price having continued its correction.

In the instances when price does continue with its correction against the main trend then I will have cut my losses early and will have kept more of my trading capital intact for when the main trend does resume.

Another potential positive to not holding positions open against me so far into the red is that I could slightly increase the gearing of my Q3 and Q4 trades. Bread and butter trades in the upper half of the grid are currently nowhere near as profitable as those in the lower half, purely due to the much lower gearing of those entries.

Should I cut my Q3 and Q4 trades much earlier if they are going against me? Would it be advantageous to increase the gearing of my Q3 and Q4 trades knowing that tighter stops are in place and the use of the Anti-Hedge technique is going to get me back in?

These are the sorts of questions currently percolating in the back of my mind. I’m leaving it to my subconscious to sort through all the options. I’m sure that over the coming days and weeks I’ll decide which way to go.

Keys to trading success

One of the very first statistics that most people come across as they start out on their trading adventure is that 95% of traders lose money. I’m sure that each and every one of those people thought to themselves, “I’m going to be one of the winning 5%”. I know I certainly did.

Another revealing statistic that people might not be so familiar with comes from a study of the 1980 U.S. Department of Labor Statistics and Mortality Tables as to what happens to people between their twenty-fifth and sixty-fifth birthday: only seven percent of them became financially secure enough to retire comfortably. That leaves 93% who achieve poverty.

95% of traders lose money; 93% of people in the U.S., the most successful and prosperous nation this planet has ever seen, end up broke at the end of forty or fifty years of work. An uncanncy parrallel don’t you think?

What should these figures tell you?

To me it signifies that the commonly held wisdom on how to make money is wrong. Similarly, the commonly held wisdom on how to trade is wrong. If the commonly held wisdom was right then every trader would be rich, and 93% of the US population wouldn’t be retiring in the poor house.

Throw out that common wisdom and focus on what helped those who were successful get to where they are.

You don’t need to re-invent the wheel on how to become a successful trader. You could try and do it all on your own, but why would you want to go through all that hardship and struggle? Find a successful trader who you admire and respect. Someone whose methodology meshes well with your personality.

Thus the first key to trading success is to have a mentor.

We have all had, hopefully, great teachers in our life. They helped us achieve knowledge, avoided pitfalls and problems along the way, preventing us from making the same mistakes that others have made. A mentor should be able to transfer knowledge of techniques and insight that results in a much faster educational experience for the student, compared to having to learn everything on their own. The mentor can help steer the student’s progress, helping them in areas where they are naturally weak, and letting the student tackle on their own areas where they are strong.

I have learned more and gained more confidence in my own trading abilities in the one year that I have had a mentor than in the previous three or four years that I struggled on my own.

The second key to trading success can be summed up by one of Einstein’s famous quotes: ‘Make things as simple as possible, but no simpler’. When I say simple, just how simple do I mean?

Pretty damn simple. You should be able to explain your trading methodology to a six-year-old, and have them fully understand it.

Trading is not rocket science. Wall Street, and by inference your retail broker, would like to make you think different, with their huge array of researchers, analysts, quants, automated mechanical systems and other magical seeming flashy gadgets.

To look behind the curtain and see that the Wizard ain’t all he seems, all you have to do is be aware of hedge fund companies such as Long Term Capital Management, who collapsed spectacularly back in 1998, even with all the Noble-prize winning economists on their staff, or the huge loses suffered by Amaranth (another hedge fund) earlier this year. These ‘black swan’ events happen all the time, no matter how much the number crunchers on Wall Street would have you believe that that one in a billion chance will never happen in our lifetimes.

The markets are made up other people. Flesh and blood human beings just like you. Fear and greed drive those people to make their decisions to buy and sell. Simple. Keep it simple.

How do you keep your trading methodoly simple? Get rid of the fluff, so that you can focus on the important core factors. Once you are an expert on the basics then you can broaden your range.

There are four core factors that I was primarily taught to focus on by my mentor, and which are described in more detail in the book Bird Watching in Lion Country. I will go through each of them briefly, to show how keeping things as simple as possible is to your advantage.

One currency pair
In the world of investing, diversification can be a very good thing. On the other hand, when you want to actively trade and make your gains through speculation, then you need to specialize as much as possible to start with.

Since I focus my trading pretty much exclusively on the arena of forex trading, all my examples will deal with this area.

Working with just one currency pair allows you to focus on just the factors that affect that pair. You are able to learn the ins-and-outs of the two currencies that make up that pair.

With the US dollar still as the world’s reserve currency, the vast majority of foreign exchange transactions that take place on any given day are US dollar denominated. This is why the majority of forex liquidity is found in the following three pairs: EUR-USD, GBP-USD and USD-JPY.

Pick one of these three main pairs and get to know it like the back of your hand. There will be nothing stopping you from trading multiple pairs in the future, when you are more experienced and knowledgeable. Working with multiple pairs to begin with only increases your workload, when what you need to be doing is minimizing your workload so that you can focus on the other aspects of your trading approach.

One direction
One of the main factors that will make up your trading edge (the core reason or rationale of how you are able to take money from the market) is derived from picking the long-term directional trend that your chosen currency pair is currently in. The rational for this is again to simplify things as much as possible. Forex markets are well known for being well-trending markets, where price moves in the same direction for long periods of time. The reason for these one directional moves over such a sustained period of time is generally driven by the economic fundamentals of the countries whose currencies make up the currency pair.

In the more short- to medium-term, the currency will do one of three things: move up, move down, or move sideways.

When you know what your one direction is you are then only allowed to place trades that are in line with that direction. For example, if your one direction is long on the EUR-USD pair, then you will only ever place buy (long) orders.

By trading in only the direction of what we have identified as the long-term trend direction, we are able to make money on moves that move up or move sideways. We will only have to sustain loses when price moves down.

Your mentor can certainly help you in deciding what your one direction should currently be. As the economic reality of the countries that make up your pair change, you have to decide if your current one direction should change or stay the same. You must use your brain in making this decision, and keep using your brain to re-evaluate it on a constant basis.

Another added benefit of only trading in one direction is that you won’t keep constantly second guessing yourself if you allow yourself to enter both long and short positions at any given moment. The constant, random tick price movements that exist at very short time frames will only cause you cause you undue anxiety and stress.

You will also learn to be patient if you restrict yourself to only trading in one direction. If price is currently moving against your one direction, then you have to learn how to exercise restraint, and wait until price has retraced to where you think it will bottom out before moving back in your one direction again. You soon come to learn the huge importance and advantage of how not trading is part of a successful trader’s arsenal.

Low gearing
Gearing is a term used to describe how much money you will use on any given trade. It is a core factor in understanding how you will manage your money.

Since, as part of our simplification process, we have chosen only one direction in which we are allowed to place trades, and that the direction is based on the long-term trend we foresee, we must prepare ourselves for large price movements that go against our one direction. All price movement involves retracements that occur frequently during any trending move. To withstand such adverse price movement, while at the same time allowing our trades time to mature into positive territory again, we must only allocate a small amount of capital to each and every trade. This will allow us to ride out such retracements.

It is imperative that you preserve your trading capital at all costs. The longer you can stay in the trading game the more chance that you will have of learning the necessary skills and techniques to survive and thrive.

Don’t get greedy! Trade using low gearing, prefereably through a broker that allows you to use micro lots, so that you can allocate the correct lot size to each trade entry based on how much available equity you have in your trading account.

Cut profits short, let your losses run
This core factor flies against most of the teachings that you will come across from other traders. While at the same time, it is a successfully used technique in the world of stock and mutual fund trading.

All you have to do is remind yourself that 95% of traders lose money. I’m sure the vast majority of those traders did some research and came across the mantra of ‘cut your losses, and let your profits run’. It didn’t save them from losing money, and more than likely, it won’t help you either.

Trading can be a fickle game; you have to take your profit whenever you can. Remember the ryhme you heard as a kid: ‘An apple a day keeps the doctor away’. In the trading arena it’s: ‘Profits every day keep the bailiff away’.

Of course, what this means in practice is that you will end up taking small, frequent profits. Since loses are a fact of trading life you must also know when you are going to take them and why. You take loses when the fundmental reasons why you are entering trades in your one direction begin to no longer hold true.

To be profitable you only need to have your numerous small profits exceed your rare larger loses. If price is rangebound or moves in your one direction then this scenario will hold true and you make money. In cases where price makes a sustained move against your one direction you will experience loses. Since loses are an everyday part of a trader’s life, you have to learn to take these loses in your stride as you continue be forward looking, focusing on the future direction of the market. Again, the process of preserving your capital is paramount, which is why using low gearing will result in relatively minor losses compared to what you might experience if you utilize the full leverage that many brokers provide.

In the long run (i.e. over the months and years), if your reading of the market is correct, and you have been able to keep on the right side of the long term trend more often than not, you will have achieved what 95% of traders are unable to: profitable success.

Having such mental fortitude to handle all the various emotions that are part and parcel of a trader’s every day activity is paramount. The third key to successful trading that I want to cover is how to achieve this mental strength.

A trader’s psyche has a huge influence on their ability to make decisions and perform to the best of their ability. Every person is different, and thus every person has their own mental strengths and weaknesses.

It is important to make an effort to discover what your mental weaknesses are, and to try and either eradicate them or else to turn them into strengths. This can only be achieved by pursueing a journey of personnal development. This is one of the most rewarding aspects of being a trader; being always on the lookout on how to better yourself.

The importance of a trader’s psychology can not be understated. Once you have been trading for a while, you really do begin to see how vital this aspect is in becoming a successful trader.

If you’ve always dismissed how much impact your own psychology has on your performance as a trader, I urge you to take active steps to at least learn the basics. Especially on how the mental programming that we have acquired throughout our lives can be impacting on our thinking and decision making processes.

While there are many different roads to trading success, there are a few key points that can help us to get there without having to experience misfortune and misadventure:
1. Find a mentor and learn from their experience. The easiest way to be successful is to emulate that success.
2. Keep it simple. The marketing glitz put out by Wall Street and other trading marketers is just a smokescreen. You don’t need to know or understand everything to make money trading. You just need to know enough, and if you keep things simple you have a better chance of figuring what that is. Examples of using the four core factors discussed above can be found throughout my Journal postings.
3. Be self-aware. Don’t allow self-sabotage to ruin your chances. Always be on the look-out to improve yourself. In time, you yourself and those around you will thank you for it.

—-

This post was submitted as part of the 48th installment of the Carnival of Investing.

Gearing – part 2

Dirk has published his second newsletter, following up on the central issue of gearing and how utilizing high leverage is not in your best interest as a trader. As well as exploring the issue of high leverage and how it is detrimental to your long-term survival, he also shows how it is still possible to make decent returns using low leverage.

The second edition of the BWILC newsletter can be found here.